“Valuable staff”: How Kremlin is turning war participants into school teachers
Schools in Russia are not only educational institutions but also key players in the electoral process. Most polling stations are located in schools, while school staff make up the majority of election commission members.
To address the shortage of teachers in small towns and villages, Kremlin is now retraining 'war veterans' as educators.
This reportage explains how it works.
Read more … “Valuable staff”: How Kremlin is turning war participants into school teachers
Who funds United Russia?
The wealthiest political party in Russia, which has maintained a dominant position in power for over 20 years, receives annual funds large enough to cover the expenses of a small town.
Sirena project conducted a thorough analysis of the party’s financial report, identifying its key sources of support.
REM summarizes its main findings.
Report: COVID-19 pandemic and war have not altered the funding system of Russian political parties
According to the recent Golos report, the rules meant to ensure financial transparency of political parties are not functioning as intended.
Instead, parties have become more secretive and learned to circumvent legal restrictions.
REM shares key findings of the report.
Trauma of repression: How state persecution of Russian activists alters their lives
1,073 individuals in Russia have been subjected to political repression, with 331 currently in prison.
REM presents an abridged translation of a 7х7 reportage on the trauma of political repression.
Its heroes' personal accounts highlight the reasons behind low political engagement in Russia.
Read more … Trauma of repression: How state persecution of Russian activists alters their lives
Honorary pension for Ukrainian elites
For years, the Kremlin has sought to incorporate Ukrainian politicians, security officials and bureaucrats loyal to it into its power structure.
However, after the annexation of Crimea and the start of the full-scale invasion, its policy underwent significant changes.
In this essay, Andrey Pertsev analyzes the Kremlin's new strategy to win over Ukrainian officials dissatisfied with the Ukrainian leadership.
Immunity from the military: How Russia's power vertical resists career advancement of the “special military operation” participants
Vladimir Putin often refers to participants in the war as the "true elite".
However, the results of the regional elections show that the system is not ready to place 'frontline soldiers' in key positions, and the military itself is not keen to pursue deputy roles, which are often unpaid.
CPRF: Does the “party of the past” have a future?
What is the Communist Party of the Russian Federation undergoing amidst the war and the totalitarian evolution of Putin’s regime?
Does it stand any chance of surviving Putin? And what can the CPRF’s past reveal about its future?
Journalist Azamat Izmailov traces the party’s evolution.
Read more … CPRF: Does the “party of the past” have a future?
Without respect for fundamental freedoms: Ten reasons why Russian elections and their results cannot be considered democratic
Due to repressions against the observers, reduced number of parties and remote e-voting system, the results of the September elections were contrary to the statutes of international law.
Media monitoring: After the elections
REM commissioned an independent team of analysts to monitor Russia's leading social networks, VKontakte, Odnoklassniki, Telegram and Youtube, to explore how the Kremlin's propaganda machine works on social media using actual data.
We present the main observations below, as well as visualized data and graphs illustrating the findings.
Statement of the Golos movement on the results of the regional elections of 6-8 September 2024
The Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights Golos has published a final statement on the results of the regional elections in Russia in September 2024.
REM presents an abridged English version of the statement.
Express review of the third voting day on 8 September
Based on the Golos report, REM summarizes the key trends observed during the third voting day (Unified Election Day) of the regional elections 2024.
Read more … Express review of the third voting day on 8 September
Express review of the second voting day on 7 September
Based on the Golos report, REM summarizes the key trends observed during the second voting day of the regional elections 2024.
Read more … Express review of the second voting day on 7 September
Media monitoring: Before the elections
REM commissioned an independent team of analysts to monitor Russia's leading social networks, VKontakte, Odnoklassniki, Telegram and Youtube, to explore how the Kremlin's propaganda machine works on social media using actual data.
We present the main observations below, as well as visualized data and graphs illustrating the findings.
Express review of the first voting day on 6 September
Based on the Golos report, REM summarizes the key trends observed during the first voting day of the regional elections 2024.
Read more … Express review of the first voting day on 6 September
"We don't need a woman, she won't be able to manage our district". How Russian women are running for office
In 6-8 September elections, 83 men and only 12 women are running for governor in 21 regions.
Being a female politician in Russia means facing numerous challenges.
7x7 shares stories of women who stand for office in 2024.
Kaliningrad region: The political landscape before the elections
How has Russia’s invasion of Ukraine affected the situation in the Kaliningrad region? What is the background and what should we expect in the upcoming regional elections?
Journalist and activist Roman Kolevatov answers these questions.
Read more … Kaliningrad region: The political landscape before the elections
The phantom of competition
To let disgruntled voters blow off steam, Kremlin has returned to the theme of "competitive elections" for the first time in many years.
However, in the absence of real competition such strategy may backfire.
Andrey Pertsev explains why Kremlin creates an illusion of contest in predictable elections.
Competitive elections in Russia remain only at the local level
By-elections to the State Duma, elections to regional and local legislatures, as well as elections for heads of municipalities and local councils, will take place in the regions of Russia on 6-8 September 2024.
Observers prepared a final report on the results of candidate nominations and registrations.
REM publishes an executive summary.
Read more … Competitive elections in Russia remain only at the local level
“We will start small”
How can a deputy of a city duma help people?
Why are trade unions so important for Russia?
What will make sanctions a fairer political tool?
Evgeny Stupin, deputy of the Moscow City Duma, was stripped of his deputy's mandate because of his anti-war stance. In this interview, he talks about his achievements and plans.
Beglov — a riddle of Putinism?
Why will the most unpopular governor of Saint Petersburg win the upcoming election? And how is Beglov significant to the Kremlin and to Putin personally?
Political observer Maksim Veselov discusses how “The Beglov Era” in St. Petersburg perfectly encapsulates today’s Russia and why Beglov serves as the role model of Putin’s clerk.
Between extinction and degradation: Do systemic parties have a future?
How did “systemic parties” emerge in Russia?
What makes a political party “systemic” in general? And why does Vladimir Putin’s regime still need them?
Political researcher explores these questions.
Read more … Between extinction and degradation: Do systemic parties have a future?
No region in Russia has a competitive gubernatorial election campaign
The movement in defense of voters' rights Golos has published an analytical report on the results of nomination and registration of gubernatorial candidates.
REM summed up the main takeaways in this article.
Read more … No region in Russia has a competitive gubernatorial election campaign
Who rules Russian regions. Alexander Kynev on how the system of power has changed over 30 years
In his recently published book, Kynev described how regional politics has changed from the collapse of the USSR to the present day: how forces were distributed, how the power vertical was built, and how heads of regions turned into regular managers.
REM publishes a translation of 7x7 interview with him.
The main intrigue of September elections — will Communists regain their positions?
Russian authorities have done everything to make the elections predictable and boring, and voters hardly ever go to them at all.
And yet — should we expect something interesting from the September elections?
REM publishes a translation of the 7x7 interview with expert Alexander Kynev.
Read more … The main intrigue of September elections — will Communists regain their positions?
“I’d really like to live in Russia”
What is the meaning of clandestine electoral campaigns in modern Russia?
Could the experiences of political struggle in other countries be adopted by Russian activists in the future?
Activist and politician Ksenia Bezdenezhnykh on her electoral experience and workplace politics.
A wizard with federal connections
In June, Vladimir Putin appointed Andrey Turchak as the acting head of the Altai Republic, an economically depressive and sparsely populated region.
This appointment was seen as a "punishment" for Turchak's continued good relations with Yevgeny Prigozhin, founder of the Wagner private military company.
Meduza tells how Andrei Turchak is trying to please Altai residents and earn his return to Moscow.
Kremlin plans to reelect Alexander Beglov as governor of St. Petersburg
In September 2024, Vladimir Putin’s hometown will elect its governor. Most likely, it will again be the Kremlin's protégé Alexander Beglov.
Presidential Administration's documents leaked to the journalists of “Vot tak” indicate that the entire campaign is managed from a single center, and Beglov’s rivals are carefully selected candidates with no chance of winning.
“Vot tak” reveals how Kremlin is running a fake campaign that costs 1.8 mln USD.
Read more … Kremlin plans to reelect Alexander Beglov as governor of St. Petersburg
"Admitting helplessness is much scarier than the situation in Russia"
Vladimir Zhilkin is an anti-war candidate for the Moscow City Duma. He is a politician, human rights activist and sociologist from Tambov, a provincial city 500 km from Moscow.
REM publishes an abridged translation of Zhilkin's interview for 7x7, where he talks about his campaign, Muscovites' attitudes towards the war, and why it is important to run for election even when there are no free elections.
Read more … "Admitting helplessness is much scarier than the situation in Russia"
Moscow Mayor's Office decided not to allow opposition candidates to City Duma elections and to conduct the campaign quietly
The Moscow parliament should be ‘maximally cleared’ of opposition candidates, with 'Sobyanin's people' taking their place. The election campaign should not attract unnecessary attention.
According to sources of the Verstka media, these are the objectives set by the Moscow mayor's office for the upcoming elections on 8 September.
“I’m not going to leave my neighborhood”
Gleb Babich's campaign was one of the most remarkable campaigns in this year's Moscow City Duma elections.
On 16 July, Moscow Election Commission declared 8% of signatures collected by Gleb Babich invalid. The left-leaning urban activist will not be registered as a candidate.
In this interview, he talks about the goals and challenges of his campaign as well as the meaning of collective discussion and action in today’s Russia.
Election update IX. Russia begins preparations for Unified Voting Day 2024
In September, elections will be held for 13 regional legislatures and 22 governors.
Kremlin is actively preparing by further restricting both the citizens’s voting rights and political competition in 'problematic' regions.
More about the election-related developments of May/June 2024 in this review.
Read more … Election update IX. Russia begins preparations for Unified Voting Day 2024
'They decide who lives, who gets imprisoned, and who gets elected'. Russia bans 'foreign agents' from elections
Recently the parliament of Georgia, despite widespread public unrest and warnings from the EU, passed a law on 'foreign agents', commonly referred to as 'the Russian law'.
In this article, REM discusses the evolution of the legislation on foreign agents in Russia and the recent legislative amendments on the participation of 'foreign agents' in elections.
"Something's been tweaked somewhere!": Participants in the war in Ukraine ran in Russian elections and failed
Despite being given advantages, only 19 war participants won ‘passable’ parliamentary seats in United Russia primaries.
How was this even possible? Read in the article by Verstka.
When did it all go so horribly wrong? The Russian opposition turns to introspection
The Anti-Corruption Foundation’s latest documentary series with the heavy title Traitors raises complex questions about the 1990s as a myth and as an actual historical period that had consequences for the present - questions about opposition strategy, communication style, political platform and Russia’s possible future.
In this essay, Dr. Ilya Matveev reflects on each of these questions in turn.
Read more … When did it all go so horribly wrong? The Russian opposition turns to introspection
Russian expatriate voting: Generational divides, gender gap and electoral manipulations
How do Russians living abroad vote and what factors drive their electoral behavior?
In the presidential election 2024, volunteers conducted exit poll surveys in 44 countries where Russian citizens cast their votes.
The results identify the most problematic polling places with significant discrepancies between survey results and official voting results.
Read more … Russian expatriate voting: Generational divides, gender gap and electoral manipulations
Parties in a coma
The results of presidential campaign 2024 raise questions about the future of the party system.
For the first time in the post-Soviet history of Russia, none of the parliamentary candidates gained more than 5% of the vote - at least according to the official data.
This means the party machinery for mobilizing core supporters is virtually inoperative.
As Putin enters his fifth term, what transformations is Russian party system going through? An analysis by Riddle.
The new Kadyrov. Who could become the next head of the Chechen Republic?
Although the 47-year-old Chechnya's leader Ramzan Kadyrov denies rumors about his potentially fatal illness, media and experts on Russian elites claim that Kremlin has begun to develop a plan for power transfer.
What kind of person does Kremlin need to be in charge of Chechnya, and who are potential candidates for this post – in REM's review.
Read more … The new Kadyrov. Who could become the next head of the Chechen Republic?
Election update VIII. Preparations for the Unified Election Day 2024 have started
United Russia tries hard to nominate war veterans for regional parliaments, the party system continues to decline, while Chechnya acknowledges the use of coercion to vote in the last presidential elections.
More about the election-related developments of March/April 2024 in this review.
Read more … Election update VIII. Preparations for the Unified Election Day 2024 have started
An undesirable cudgel
In the first three months of 2024, Russian authorities declared more organizations “undesirable” than in the full year of 2022.
The law on undesirable organizations was adopted in 2015. Foreign NGOs labeled “undesirable” are banned from establishing legal entities, disseminating information and implementing programs in Russia.
This long read examines how the legislation on undesirable organizations has evolved since then and how the law is enforced today.
Russian opposition: A strategic impasse
The current state of opposition politics in Russia is paradoxical. Despite commanding considerable resources, the opposition has not had any strategic or even tactical successes for a long time.
In this essay, a political scientist discusses the impasse in which the Russian opposition finds itself and outlines three areas for strategic discussion about its future.
Vote report. How Kremlin uses social media to control and boost turnout
REM commissioned an independent team of analysts to monitor Russia's leading social networks, VKontakte and Telegram, to show how the Kremlin's propaganda machine works on social media.
Here are the results of social media monitoring during the voting days on March 16-18, 2024.
Read more … Vote report. How Kremlin uses social media to control and boost turnout
Electoral anomaly in Cyprus. How Foreign Ministry and CEC fabricated 40,000 votes for Putin
We collected evidence demonstrating why the presidential vote 2024 in Cyprus can be considered the largest overseas electoral fraud in Russia's modern history.
Fire, ink, Noon against Putin: How Russians resisted illegitimate elections
Russia's three-day presidential vote 2024 seemed to be the most non-transparent in its history.
In this article, we provide an overview of the civic resistance at polls during the voting days.
Read more … Fire, ink, Noon against Putin: How Russians resisted illegitimate elections
22 million fake votes for Putin? How Kremlin rigged the election results 2024
Various methods of data analysis can be used to detect electoral fraud.
Several investigative teams counted that at least 22 million votes — a third of the 65 million ballots cast for Vladimir Putin — were cast fraudulently. Keep reading to find out how it works.
Read more … 22 million fake votes for Putin? How Kremlin rigged the election results 2024
Statement on the Russian presidential elections 2024
Based on Golos observers' reports, REM summarizes the three-day presidential vote results and reports on electoral violations.
Read more … Statement on the Russian presidential elections 2024
Express review of the third voting day on 17 March
Based on the Golos report, REM summarizes the key trends observed during the third voting day of the presidential election 2024.
Read more … Express review of the third voting day on 17 March
Express review of the second and beginning of the third voting days on 16-17 March
Based on the Golos report, REM summarizes key trends observed during the second and the beginning of the third voting days of the presidential election 2024.
Read more … Express review of the second and beginning of the third voting days on 16-17 March
Express review of the first voting day on 15 March
Based on the Golos report, REM summarizes the key trends observed during the first voting day of the presidential election 2024.
Read more … Express review of the first voting day on 15 March
Russia uses social media as a major campaigning tool in its presidential elections
REM commissioned an independent team of analysts to monitor Russia's leading social networks, VKontakte and Telegram, to show how the Kremlin's propaganda machine works on social media.
Here we present the main findings, fascinating data, and diagrams revealing the mechanisms behind this massive propaganda machine.
Read more … Russia uses social media as a major campaigning tool in its presidential elections
Election update VII. The campaign results: Russian authorities make the election run dry
In this article, REM summarizes the results of the presidential election campaign 2024, focusing on agitation and administrative mobilization.
The text is based on the respective report published by the election watchdog Golos.
Read more … Election update VII. The campaign results: Russian authorities make the election run dry
How the authorities allure Russians to the election to increase the turnout
In regimes such as Russia's, a typical voter lacks motivation to participate in the elections due to the high predictability of the outcome.
At the same time, election organizers need to ensure a high turnout to show that the society is not tired of its national leader even after decades of his rule.
How do they do it? Find out in this long read.
Read more … How the authorities allure Russians to the election to increase the turnout
Navigating opposition strategies in presidential election 2024
As the presidential vote looms, Russian opposition is trying to develop the most sensible voting strategy.
Although the whole setup is highly orchestrated, three options are on the table. What are they?
Read more … Navigating opposition strategies in presidential election 2024
Who is Vladislav Davankov – a new hope for opposition in the presidential election?
After the CEC refused to register Ekaterina Duntsova and Boris Nadezhdin, it became clear - in presidential election 2024, there will be no one on the ballot who opposes the war in Ukraine and criticizes the government.
Nevertheless, prominent opposition leaders continue to agitate Russians to go to the polls and vote for "anyone but Putin". The most obvious choice for many is Vladislav Davankov, a presidential candidate from the New People party.
Read more … Who is Vladislav Davankov – a new hope for opposition in the presidential election?
In Memoriam: Alexei Navalny (1976 - 2024)
Reflecting on Alexei Navalny's political journey, this text recognizes his substantial impact on Russian elections - for both the past and probably the future.
Navalny played a crucial part in enlightening Russian society about elections through his campaigns, emerging as a symbol of will and hope for the most thoughtful segment of the population.
His legacy leaves an enduring mark on the landscape of Russian politics, which will not disappear with his murder.
Election update VI. Results of presidential elections 2024 candidates registration
Golos, the Movement in defense of voters' rights, has published a report summing up the results of candidates' nomination and registration during the Russian presidential election campaign 2024.
In this review, we share the main takeaways.
Read more … Election update VI. Results of presidential elections 2024 candidates registration
How voter signatures collection turned into an impassable barrier for the opposition
Boris Nadezhdin, an anti-war candidate for the Russian presidency, was not registered as such by the Russian Central Election Commission.
Being nominee of a non-parliamentary party, he needed to submit 105.000 signatures of Russian citizens in support of his candidacy. He did so, but the CEC invalidated a signification part of them.
We explain how Russian election commissions use the signatures as a tool to eliminate undesirable candidates.
Read more … How voter signatures collection turned into an impassable barrier for the opposition
Statement. Russia has declared REM an ‘undesirable organization’
On 1 February 2024, the Russian Prosecutor General's Office declared the Russian Election Monitor a so-called ‘undesirable organization’.
Read more … Statement. Russia has declared REM an ‘undesirable organization’
Who is Boris Nadezhdin – the anti-war candidate for the Russian presidency?
Many are convinced that Nadezhdin's nomination is a well thought out plan orchestrated by the presidential administration. Even his surname has roots in the word "hope" in Russian.
Yet, these rumors have not prevented Nadezhdin from gaining almost unanimous support of Russian opposition and eventually becoming the only presidential hopeful with anti-war agenda.
Read more … Who is Boris Nadezhdin – the anti-war candidate for the Russian presidency?
Presidential elections 2024: Does the opposition have a chance?
REM asked a political analyst whether the opposition, both systemic and exiled, has a chance for success in the upcoming presidential election.
Read more … Presidential elections 2024: Does the opposition have a chance?
It’s the taking part that counts. What strategy will the opposition have for the presidential elections?
On January 14, representatives of Russian exiled opposition participated in a live broadcast on TV Rain to discuss their strategy for the upcoming elections in March 2024.
REM publishes a short summary of participants’ suggestions.
Election update V. Putin's presidential campaign has been rigged from the start
Russian CEC adopted regulations for candidates to run for the presidency. Predictably, not all applicants were able to obtain the status of a registered candidate. Meanwhile, the election campaign of incumbent President Vladimir Putin started with violations of electoral legislation.
In this review, we briefly recap the most significant events of late 2023 and early 2024.
Read more … Election update V. Putin's presidential campaign has been rigged from the start
Presidential elections 2024: Is there going to be a change in Russia?
REM asked a political analyst about socio-cultural differences between Russian regions and how they affect the voting results.
Read more … Presidential elections 2024: Is there going to be a change in Russia?
Dissent of the loyal: Women’s protest on the eve of the presidential campaign in Russia
After 600 days of genocidal war in Ukraine, dozens of women - mothers, wives and sisters - attempted to rally demanding the return of their loved ones home.
Any manifestation of dissent is an unlikely event these days in Russia due to the highly repressive environment and immediate crackdown on any instance of public discontent.
Read more … Dissent of the loyal: Women’s protest on the eve of the presidential campaign in Russia
How the Russian opposition is preparing for 2024 presidential elections
Vladimir Putin is to stand for a fifth term. Little doubt remains that Kremlin will make every effort to keep him in power.
Can the upcoming vote become a window of opportunity for a democratic regime change?
Here we explain how the quite fragmented Russian opposition intends to act in the presidential elections 2024 and what it recommends to the voters.
Read more … How the Russian opposition is preparing for 2024 presidential elections
Election update IV. Russia's presidential campaign is gathering pace
In this report, we recount the most significant November 2023 developments related to the presidential elections 2024.
Among them are Putin's presidential bid, test of e-voting, amendments to legislation on presidential elections and political “cleansings” in Russian regions.
The report is based on a regular news digest by the Golos Movement for Defense of Voters' Rights.
Read more … Election update IV. Russia's presidential campaign is gathering pace
Who is Ekaterina Duntsova – a candidate for the Russian presidency?
“Every day the life of ordinary Russians is becoming more difficult. Citizens cannot freely express their opinion if it does not coincide with the position of the authorities; the number of political prisoners is growing, hundreds of thousands of people have been forced out of the country. <...>
“Military operations” on the territory of neighboring states lead to imminent isolation and degradation”, her campaign website says.
Read more … Who is Ekaterina Duntsova – a candidate for the Russian presidency?
Russian presidential elections 2024: Is resistance at polls possible?
The election on 17 March 2024 will be the first presidential election during the war in recent Russian history. Further, it will be the first presidential election after the constitutional amendments 2020 that nullified the count of consecutive presidential terms and allowed Vladimir Putin to stay in power until 2036.
We asked an expert if there is any room for maneuver for opposition voters, given the unprecedented level of political constraints.
Read more … Russian presidential elections 2024: Is resistance at polls possible?
"We’ll have no time to celebrate the victory before the great lent"
In March 2024 election, Vladimir Putin should receive at least 80% of the votes with a turnout of 80%. According to “Verstka”, these are the benchmarks that the Kremlin's domestic policy bloc is setting for the Russian authorities.
The campaign slogan consists of three words: “Pride. Hope. Confidence”. The heroes of the “Special Military Operation” will also be invited to become Putin's confidants; however, the main focus won’t be set on them or on the war itself.
Read more … "We’ll have no time to celebrate the victory before the great lent"
Election update III. The presidential campaign in Russia has started
In this one-pager, REM recounts the most significant October 2023 events signaling the start of the campaign.
The text is based on an analytical report prepared by experts and published on the Golos Movement for Defense of Voters' Rights website.
Read more … Election update III. The presidential campaign in Russia has started
The first post-Putin elections: What they might look like
How to organize a fair voting system in post-Putin Russia? How elections should be arranged and who should be responsible for this? What principles of representation should be taken into account?
Political scientist Grigory Golosov discusses these and other questions in this article.
Read more … The first post-Putin elections: What they might look like
Opposition coalition: A good thing or “To hell with it”?
On 25 September, supporters of Alexei Navalny published a large text in which he rejected a coalition with the rest of the opposition. On the same day, Maxim Katz released a video where he disagreed with Navalny and called on “dissenters” to unite before the presidential elections in 2024.
In this article, political scientist Grigory Golosov explains which of the two strategies is more effective, and whether political coalitions in modern Russia make any sense at all.
Read more … Opposition coalition: A good thing or “To hell with it”?
Free elections post-Putin: Not a cure-all
The demand for free elections should be an indisputable cornerstone of any democratic reform program. That is why it is a common belief that the first order of business after the fall of the current regime in Russia should be to conduct free nationwide elections.
Political scientist Grigory Golosov argues that despite the importance of elections, this issue should not be the first on the agenda and explains why.
Online elections in Russia. What to expect from them?
Over the span of several election cycles, e-voting in Russia has proved to be a black box serving the regime’s needs.
After its launch in just a handful of regions, it is now expected to become available to all Russians in the 2024 presidential elections to facilitate fraud and deliver an overwhelming vote share for Vladimir Putin.
Read more … Online elections in Russia. What to expect from them?
Three politicians who opposed the war and won the elections
After the Russian invasion of Ukraine, most deputies who openly disagreed with Putin's war were sent to pre-trial detention centers or 'squeezed out' of the country.
However, despite the total suppression of the freedom of speech and assembly, there are still municipal politicians in Russia who openly oppose the war and win local elections.
We share the stories of three such heroes.
Read more … Three politicians who opposed the war and won the elections
Putin’s electoral theatre: Past, present and future
On 8-10 September 2023, Russia held local elections in two dozen different regions. The Kremlin could have easily canceled them by declaring martial law. Instead, elections were held in the newly occupied areas of Ukraine despite martial law. This suggests that Putin’s regime still finds sham elections useful.
This essay provides a brief history of elections in post-Soviet Russia, exploring the latest example of the Kremlin’s sham democracy and sketches the prospects of political changes.
Read more … Putin’s electoral theatre: Past, present and future
Elections without change?
Do observers in Russia possess the tools to maintain independent oversight of elections? How has the war influenced the pre-election campaign? Can the recent vote even be described as an election? What is the Russian government's motive for holding such “elections”, and what might we anticipate from the 2024 presidential campaign?
To find out, read this interview with experts.
Elections 2023 appear even less free and fair than before
8-10 September in Russia were days of elections of State Duma deputies in four districts, heads of 21 regions, deputies of 16 regional parliaments, 12 city councils of regional capitals, as well as elections in the occupied territories and numerous local elections.
REM summarizes the main conclusions from the observation.
Read more … Elections 2023 appear even less free and fair than before
What are the opportunities for the opposition in Russian elections?
The electoral and civil rights legislation in Russia is getting stricter year by year, leaving very little room for oppositional politics. What can opponents of the regime achieve in the face of constantly introduced obstacles?
In this article, we reflect on whether there is any room left for opposition politicians in Russia, and if it makes sense for them to participate in elections at all.
Read more … What are the opportunities for the opposition in Russian elections?
Spoilers and doppelgängers in Russian elections
The practice of nominating namesake candidates or similar-looking candidates is widely used in Russian elections.
In this article, we explain how this electoral technology works to mislead the voter and pull votes away from the opposition.
What are the specifics of Russian parliamentarism?
Do elections have any value in a country with strong repressive machinery where any politician whom the authorities may consider dangerous can be placed in jail?
The author of this article is convinced that elections in Russia present not only a high-cost ritual spectacle simulating democracy but also largely shape the interaction between the state and society.
Keep reading to find out more.
Read more … What are the specifics of Russian parliamentarism?
We are observing a decline in the willingness of parties to participate in elections
Parties are reluctant to participate in elections to regional and municipal assemblies, an expert report concludes. They understand the impossibility of fair competition and do not want to invest effort in fighting the ruling party. Further, the elections in the occupied territories cannot be considered legitimate either legally or procedurally.
Read more about the results of the nomination of candidates for deputies of local and regional parliaments.
Read more … We are observing a decline in the willingness of parties to participate in elections
‘Golos’ summarized the nomination of candidates for the 2023 gubernatorial elections
The report’s primary conclusion aligns with expert forecasts: genuine competition between candidates is anticipated in only one region, the Republic of Khakassia, out of the 21 regions that participate in the September elections.
Read this report summary for more statistics and expert insights.
Read more … ‘Golos’ summarized the nomination of candidates for the 2023 gubernatorial elections
A slow death of municipal autonomy in Russia
This article delves into the process of elimination of municipal autonomy from the 2010s to the present, leading us through a series of reforms that have helped Kremlin build the so-called ‘power vertical’.
A gradual transition from weak, but somewhat independent local governance toward loyal local appointees contributes to our understanding of how political decision-making works in high-capacity authoritarian states like Russia.
If there is Putin, there are no debates
This year, Khakassia emerged as the sole Russian region where its governor, communist Valentin Konovalov, invited his adversary, Sergey Sokol from United Russia, to a debate. While the audience hoped for a substantive political exchange, the discourse was dominated by accusations of mudslinging and chasing hype.
This article explores how debates in modern Russia have changed, why gubernatorial candidates avoid open discussions with opponents, and what the future holds for debates.
Why the war did not become the main topic of the election campaign
In the past, parties and candidates would offer distinct promises to voters, address social concerns, and even position themselves against the government. However, the current campaigns appear lackluster and devoid of a clear message. Even the topic of war is scarcely touched upon by the primary candidates.
This REM review explores why the war in Ukraine hasn't emerged as the predominant topic of the recent election campaign.
Read more … Why the war did not become the main topic of the election campaign
United Russia dominates district electoral commissions, where most electoral fraud originates
A recently published "Golos" report details who holds control over the precinct electoral commissions across Russian regions. REM provides insights into the key findings of the report, emphasizing its significance as we approach the 2023 elections and the 2024 presidential elections.
Voting under bullets and shells
Holding elections in the occupied territories of Ukraine on 8-10 September is a daunting task for the Russian authorities.
This long read explores how the ongoing military actions affect election preparations and how the Kremlin is making sure that there are no surprises.
Co-chair of Russian election watchdog Golos detained ahead of elections
Mass searches and interrogations of Golos activists took place across the country. What do we know about that by now?
Read more … Co-chair of Russian election watchdog Golos detained ahead of elections
Election update II. Legislative changes make it easier for "United Russia" to win elections
On the eve of the elections, Russian authorities adopted a new package of amendments to the electoral legislation. The changes aim to help candidates from the ruling party win in the September elections.
"The current government is not going anywhere". On political changes in Russia
Wagner's rebellion showed how weak President Putin's support base is. However, no real political changes followed. Are they even possible in modern Russia, and could elections - an instrument specially invented by the democratic world for this purpose - contribute to the changes?
Read more … "The current government is not going anywhere". On political changes in Russia
The Just Russia party distances itself from regional elections following the Wagner mutiny
News on Just Russia's withdrawal of electoral activity in the regions began to emerge shortly after Prigozhin's uprising in June 2023. Expert opinions differ: some believe it signals the falling from favor for the systemic opposition, while others argue that the party uses the uprising as a rhetorical cover-up for the internal splits.
Election update I. There will be no competition in the Russian gubernatorial elections 2023
In light of the gubernatorial elections to be held in September in 21 Russian regions, we analyze a report on the candidates running for governor. The report concludes that no real competition can be expected in these elections, with few exceptions.
Approval ratings do not predict change or Why we should stop gazing at political polls from Russia
Prigozhin's failed mutiny on June 24th sparked various speculations concerning his support among the Russian population.
In times of political turbulence, approval ratings become subject to interpretations fueled by the hope of regime collapse. An expert explains why putting so much trust in politicians’ approval ratings originating from today’s Russia might be delusional.
Playing heroes
All the proclamations about the active involvement of 'war veterans' in politics remain empty rhetoric.
In reality, the 'defenders of Donbass' hat is now worn by the same politicians who have held official positions for years. This verbiage and masquerade are designed not to please the voters but to satisfy one particular person.
The thing
As it turned out at legal proceedings held on the 9th of March, proving the illegality and inadequacy of the online voting system used in Moscow's elections in 2022 wasn't rocket science or high mathematics. On the contrary, it was as easy as asking for a certificate!
Moscow's i-voting system is not lawfully certified and contradicts legal requirements, court investigations revealed.
The martial electoral law
Again and again, the Duma adjusts electoral legislation to suit its current needs. This time the main innovation appears to be a "remote election" regime for the occupied territories. This squaring of the circle would allow martial law to stay and elections to be held concurrently.
Transcending 'unlimited potential for fraud'
For years, Moscow has been a hard place to win for pro-governmental candidates. Even online voting was hardly enough to secure trouble-free victories because the citizens used the traditional method. For the mayoral campaign of 2023, a new device is invented. 40% of precinct polling stations will evaporate into the Cloud.
How to sell Putin for the fifth time
The new marketing plan for selling Putin to the voter is being developed at the Kremlin in secretive "closed seminars". The new packaging for the quarter-century-old merchandise is being tested.
But the campaign's outcome will be decided on the battlefields, not, for the first time in this century, in the Kremlin's cabinets.
On the death of the Wizard
It's hard to believe that Russian elections, nowadays a synonym of rigging, falsifications and coercion, were almost honest before this man entered the post of the chief electoral officer.
Last week, Churov, also known as the Wizard, passed away, but his malevolent curses will haunt Russian elections for years.
First elections after mobilisation
Last year the Kremlin cheated people who came to pollings station. The regime said nothing about the upcoming draft. But merely within 10 days after the polling stations were closed, the recruiting centres were unexpectedly open.
It is not possible to repeat that trick again.
The doomed Code
The Communist Party prepared their Electoral Code for consideration by the Duma. They urge to make the third Sunday in March the primary voting day, eliminate multi-day and distant electronic voting, abolish voting in streets, etc.
Arkady Lyubarev, an electoral expert, shares the secret: Why the Duma will not enact any Code, even an immaculate one.
Monitoring of the Monitors
Ordinary non-public citizens of Russia become threat number two once they acquire knowledge related to the electoral field and touch the sphere where one of the fundamental myths of the regime is created: the myth of nationwide popular support.
Slippery AstroTurf of the Kremlin war
A new study of Russian social media proved half of the sabre-rattling messages to be artificial duplicates orchestrated from the single centre. The research has also revealed prolific pro-governmental professional bloggers trying to dominate the Russian Internet community. And yet, they are 1.5 less popular than anti-war authors.
E-voting: invisible for observers, invincible for lawyers
The distant electronic voting keeps pushing the limits of our imagination. After the actual process of voting, where the entire process took place outside the view of key participants, came the legal revelation of how the lawmakers preemptively absolved themselves and the Central Election Commission of any responsibility.
Read more … E-voting: invisible for observers, invincible for lawyers
Outstanding resilience to repression and loyalty to democracy
Over 10 years, EPDE has evolved into a professional network of 16 members from Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Georgia, Germany, Hungary, Lithuania, Moldova, Norway, Poland, Sweden and Ukraine. EPDE is united in the common goal of improving democratic election processes across Europe and providing a platform for peer learning and professionalisation for its members and experts.
Read more … Outstanding resilience to repression and loyalty to democracy
Il Duce served a la Russe
The Russian people have not named Vladimir Putin Il Duce (‘The Leader’). He has been identified as such, just as earlier in history in Italy, by the elite. And as in Italy, the elimination of fascism can only be finalised by integrating the ex-fascist country into the Western world.
Unprecedentedly explicit: election observers are human right defenders!
The United Nations Special Rapporteurs on the situation of human rights defenders and on the right to freedom and peaceful assembly and of associations issued a statement on 27 October 2022 explicitly recognising citizen and international election observers as human rights defenders.
Read more … Unprecedentedly explicit: election observers are human right defenders!
The Emperor's secondhand clothes
By going to war in Ukraine, the Putin regime tried to be what it pretended to be, but its facade crashed into reality. Any myth is effective as long as its creator does not allow it to clash with reality. Skilled myth-makers know this well and guard their creations, and they do not, of course, believe in their own myths. Putin observed these rules for a long time, but he gradually began to believe in the myths that he and his entourage created and then acted in accordance with them.
Those who dared - II
We continue to acquaint our readers with those rare, brave individuals who challenged the Putin regime at home during elections in September 2022, when the regime began to receive the first sobering blows at the front in Ukraine.
What happened with the reckless candidates after the elections? How did they survive the ordeal? Who managed to stay, and who had to flee the country? You will learn it in the following, the final part of this coverage, which is currently being written exclusively for REM.
Serfs of the State
Today we will discuss budgetary workers and their role in Putin's regime. Who are the "budgetniki"? Are they the backbone of Putin's regime? In what countries and under what conditions are elections susceptible to manipulation through budgetary workers?
Those who dared
On 12 September 2022, President Zelensky announced the liberation of 6,000 km2 in a massive counter-offensive. For President Putin, the day was the beginning of a period of humiliating defeats, of the disgraceful retreat of his army and a chaotic attempt at mobilisation.
But up to this very day, there had been an election campaign in Russia. In the choking atmosphere of "special military operation", under censorship and repression for any word of dissent, there were amazing people who dared to challenge the System.
EPDE statement on house searches of Russian election observers
EPDE strongly condemns this act of repression, intimidation, and unlawful interference into citizens' constitutional right to free elections
Read more … EPDE statement on house searches of Russian election observers
It is impossible to establish the genuine will of the voters, says Golos
The election outcomes were achieved in unfree, unequal election campaigns, in an environment of restrictions on the right to be elected for a substantial number of citizens and on fundamental political rights. Under such conditions, it is impossible to establish the actual will of the voters.
Read more … It is impossible to establish the genuine will of the voters, says Golos
The third voting day in the express overview by the Russian nonpartisan election monitor Golos
By the end of voting, tension at the polling stations was growing. The number of reports claiming that commission members, police and unauthorised persons put psychological pressure on observers has also increased.
The second voting day in the express overview by the Russian nonpartisan election monitor Golos
According to Golos Movement, the main trends for the second voting day were conflicts between members of commissions and civic observers, signs of possible falsifications, and bribery and coercion of voters.
The first voting day in the express overview of the Russian nonpartisan election monitor Golos
Main election day trends: pressure on election observers and candidates, bloated turnout in Distance E-Voting, coerced voting, failure of the Electronic Voter Register, violation of the rights of election committee members, observers and mass media, fabrication of fakes and attempts to discredit citizen observers.
The 2022 elections as the last refuge of the scoundrel
Without the successes in Ukraine or on the propagandistic internal front, these elections are the last opportunity for the Kremlin to assert the concept of business-as-usual, to ensure the grip on regional assemblies. It is vital in the anticipation of an economic slump, Moreover, the new municipal structure needs a strong hand. Finally, it is a testing ground for “distant voting”, impermeable for observers.
Read more … The 2022 elections as the last refuge of the scoundrel
The ruling Russian Party of Dead Souls
This investigation is both a quantum leap in electoral observation and the most severe blow to the ruling party's reputation. As you’ll see, the findings even question who is the genuine ruling party in Russia. It was such a severe blow that Ms Pamfiliva, the chairwoman of the Russian Central Election Commission, personally reported the case to President Putin within a week of the publication.
Putin’s Second Front: no peace for the wicked
The failure of the PR campaign uncanny resembles the collapse of the military campaign on the battlefields. A new media monitoring report on "special operation" describes the unexpected resistance of the Russian population to a heavy propagandistic barrage.
No European politicians to whitewash Kremlin’s fraudulent elections or pseudo-referenda
EPDE calls on all national and regional Parliaments of the EU, the European Parliament, the PACE and the OSCE (OSCEPA) to undertake measures preventing their members from participating in illegitimate “election observation”, organized to whitewash illegal electoral processes.
Read more … No European politicians to whitewash Kremlin’s fraudulent elections or pseudo-referenda
Wartime elections
The upcoming E-day in Russia: deprived of the freedom of speech and party lists, elections are still the only way to grasp the citizens' attitude towards authorities.
Elections "in accordance with the plan"
Final part of electral fraud revelations made by the former vice-mayor of a millionaire Russian city.
Elections in a close order formation
Essential changes to Russia’s electoral legislation were introduced after its aggression against Ukraine. Indeed, one might discern some military flavour in these adjustments: discipline, unification, centralisation, monopolisation of chain of command, and elimination of tools of civil control. Dr Arkady Lyubarev, candidate of legal sciences, co-author of federal and Moscow electoral legislation, and editor in chief of the draft Electoral Code, gives his assessment of the further deterioration of the electoral system in Russia.
The nine aggrieved elects
This story is quite exceptional. We’ve never heard the testimony of electoral fraud from a witness of such high administrative rank and political status: the former vice-mayor of a millionaire city, a former head of administration of a district, a member of the regional Political Council of the United Russia Party, ruling political organisation in the country, the Secretary of the district Political Council of the party and finally, a former KGB and FSB officer. Quite an informant!
One must prepare for negative consequences – OPORA
The invaders have not been consistent in governing the temporarily occupied territories. L/DPR militants ‘appoint’ nonames to nonexistent offices in some places. In others, there are talks of holding a pseudo-referendum, and PR campaigns are run elsewhere to an incorporation in the occupied Crimea. The ‘people’s republic’ format will not work this time. However, it is still worth preparing for a negative scenario.
Read more … One must prepare for negative consequences – OPORA
To Russian opposition after the disaster of 2022: Enlighten, not repent
A. Kynev: All these hand-wringing and pathetic calls to each end everybody to repent is the utter public suicide of the opposition and a priceless gift to the government. No one has ever come to power or won an election on the pretext of humbling themselves and repenting. Therefore, this approach is an absolute dead-end and insane endeavour, at least from the electoral point of view.
Read more … To Russian opposition after the disaster of 2022: Enlighten, not repent
Elections during Russia’s ‘Special operation’
The Russian authorities keep emasculating the institution of elections and modelling it after the Belarusian version. Notably, these changes do not match too well with the allegedly increased popular support for the Russian authorities against the backdrop of the war. Instead, it demonstrates a lack of confidence that the autumn elections will go smoothly.
From election observers to ‘foreign agents’: how voters' rights defenders of the ‘Golos’ Movement are persecuted
Since September 2021, twenty regional coordinators and experts of the 'Golos' Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights were added to the registry of foreign media outlets performing the functions of 'a foreign agent'. Here's an overview of how election observers are being targeted and persecuted.
The League of Voters appeals to the ECHR
The 'League of Voters' Foundation appealed to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) for an interim measure requiring the Russian authorities not to liquidate it pending the ECHR proceedings on its earlier complaint. Should the liquidation proceed, it would make all future legal activities of the Foundation impossible: the organization would be unable to rent office space, collect donations, will lose all of its property, and would be forced to cease its human rights and educational activities.
Internet voting and shortage of candidates: how 2022 Moscow municipal elections will be held
On September 11, 2022, municipal elections will be held in 125 of Moscow's 146 districts. It is not yet known whether these elections will be a multi-day process, but it is already certain that online voting will be used again and that parties that are preparing for the elections are already facing candidate shortages. Yekaterina Grobman reviews the current situation and what we can expect in 2022.
‘Fortress’ Plan
Stanislav Andreychuk on how the Kremlin is changing laws that regulate Russia’s polity and elections to maintain the status quo.
Questionable credentials of the Russian Delegation to PACE after flawed Duma elections 2021
Independent election experts have described the 2021 Duma elections as the dirtiest elections in Russia's history. The lack of public control, the deprivation of millions of Russian citizens of their passive suffrage, massive manipulation of results through e-voting, holding of elections on the annexed territory of Crimea, and the inclusion of voters from the occupied Eastern Ukraine put the legitimacy of the current State Duma and the new PACE delegation under question.
2021 Results. Laws of the year
The passing year built on legislative trends of the previous one and even brought about many innovations in censorship, limitations of online activities, and infringements on privacy. Such provisions include multiple prohibitions related to the Great Patriotic War, the ‘law against Anti-Corruption Foundation’, and infamous QR codes.
On the liquidation of International Memorial
On 28 December 2021 Russia's Supreme Court ruled to close International Memorial. The lawsuit, filed by the Prosecutor General's Office, referred to a missing 'foreign agent' designation on some of the materials produced by International Memorial. This is only a formal pretext, though, and the court hearings showed that these allegations were groundless.
Things Will Not Be The Same: OVD-Info on the Liquidation of Memorial NGOs
OVD-Info's statement on the liquidation of its partner - the 'Memorial' Human Rights Center.
Read more … Things Will Not Be The Same: OVD-Info on the Liquidation of Memorial NGOs
Departed Russia of the Future
Hardly any of Navalny's key allies currently remain in Russia. The Insider interviewed former coordinators of Navalny's regional headquarters to find out why and how they left, what they do in exile, and under what conditions they are willing to return to Russia.
Russia is liquidating the League of Voters
On December 8, the Basmanny District Court of Moscow ruled to liquidate the 'League of Voters' Foundation. Its leaders believe that the ruling is politically motivated and is aimed to destroy the organization which is a partner in the 'Golos' Movement and supports the training of independent citizen election observers in Russia.
Created and (or) distributed: Discriminatory aspects of the application of legislation on ‘foreign agents’
OVD-Info reviews the newly expanded 'foreign agents' law to identify and analyze discriminatory aspects of the legislation and its application.
Undercover: How observers are trained at the Civic Chamber of Moscow
A member of the 'Golos' Movement for the Defense of Voters' Rights recounts their experience observing elections on behalf of the Moscow Civic Chamber. According to the activist, the institution appears to purposefully instruct observers in such a manner as to limit their ability to make a real difference at the polling stations.
Read more … Undercover: How observers are trained at the Civic Chamber of Moscow
The Party's gold. How United Russia misappropriates Russian Railways’ money under the guise of "donations"
Last year United Russia collected a record amount of donations from legal entities, 4.8 billion rubles. The Insider learned that the party received about half of this money from major Russian Railways contractors, some of which seemingly could not afford to make such "donations". Despite claiming to channel funds towards charity and fighting the Coronavirus, the party spent it on the maintenance of its apparatus and election campaigning.
‘Golos‘ Movement supports Memorial and calls for an emergency civic meeting
Russian authorities have moved to liquidate the International Historical Educational Charitable and Human Rights Society 'Memorial' and its affiliate, Russian Human Rights Centre 'Memorial'. The 'Golos' Movement calls for solidarity with Russia's longest-standing human rights organization.
Read more … ‘Golos‘ Movement supports Memorial and calls for an emergency civic meeting
Elections, totalitarian style
The political bloc of the Moscow Mayor's office has begun campaign preparations for the 2022 municipal elections. Meduza breaks down the key points in the preliminary campaign plan here.
Golos' statement on the online voting in Russian elections
Following the observation of the September 19, 2021 elections, the 'Golos' Movement stated that 'the current electronic voting system does not meet the high standards of public accountability of electoral procedures', which the Russian Constitution and legislation establish as mandatory. Despite this position, some promoters of online voting in Russia have been claiming otherwise.
Read more … Golos' statement on the online voting in Russian elections
Election Day-2021 in Bashkiria: 'Put in the target number I set'
Preliminarily evaluating the elections to the Ufa City Council and the State Duma in the Republic of Bashkortostan, the 'Golos' Movement regretfully cannot recognize the elections as truly fair, i.e., fully compliant with the Constitution, the laws of the Russian Federation, the laws of the Republic of Bashkortostan, and international election standards.
Read more … Election Day-2021 in Bashkiria: 'Put in the target number I set'
Statistical analysis of elections in Kuban
According to the analysis by Sergey Shpilkin, 889 thousand out of 1.7 million votes for United Russia in Kuban do not fall into the normal mathematical distribution. This can result from direct falsifications, pressurized voting of the employees of state-owned enterprises, public institutions, and local authorities, and the use of an administrative resource.
When they came for the Communist Party: Arrests, sieges, and pressure on supporters after the State Duma elections
The Communist Party received 19% of the votes in the last elections to the State Duma. After that, the party's supporters faced unprecedented pressure for the 'systemic opposition.' They were detained, fined, sentenced to administrative arrests, and blocked in the party premises. CPRF continues to challenge the election results and demand an investigation by the Ministry of Internal Affairs.
Hot potato: Nearly a fifth of Russia’s new State Duma deputies owe their jobs to secondhand mandates
On Tuesday, October 12, the new convocation of Russia's State Duma convened for its first session. Roughly a fifth of all lawmakers — 88 of 450 deputies — received their seats from higher-ranked candidates on party lists, winning the jobs because others didn't want them.
'Golos' Movement: It won't be easy, but we can do it
Statement of the 'Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights "Golos"' on inclusion of its members into the Foreign Agents Registry, October 5, 2021.
Read more … 'Golos' Movement: It won't be easy, but we can do it
Map of violations: three record-setting days
In total, from the beginning of voting dated September 17, 'Map of Violations' by the 'Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights "Golos"' published 4592 reports. The Map is a project that collects information about possible electoral violations using the principle of crowdsourcing – observers, voters, members of commissions may report alleged violations witnessed during the electoral campaigning or voting using a submission form on the website or a telephone hotline.
First Findings of the Moscow's Remote Electronic Voting Technical Audit
The "remote electronic voting" or online voting held in the Russian capital during the September 17-19, 2021 elections was scandalous, to say the least. In response, two groups have been formed by the Russian public to scrutinize the results.
Read more … First Findings of the Moscow's Remote Electronic Voting Technical Audit
Levels of electoral fraud in the Russian regions
In order to help assess the outcomes of 2021 State Duma elections, the 'Movement in the Defense of Voters' Rights "Golos"' provides a reference analysis, dividing Russian regions into six groups based on the level of falsifications in the federal elections of 2016 and 2018 and in the all-Russian voting in 2020.
Read more … Levels of electoral fraud in the Russian regions
Remote electronic voting: results cannot be verified
A scandal in the capital: lengthy vote tabulation, a radical overhaul of the whole election results, and shut down of the observers' node.
Read more … Remote electronic voting: results cannot be verified
2021 State Duma elections: first statistical estimates
Sergey Shpilkin analyzes data from 96,840 polling stations that cover 107.9 million registered voters out of 109.2 million on the list. His analysis demonstrates that at the polling stations where the results appear genuine, the turnout is on average 38% and the United Russia's share of votes is between 31% and 33%.
Read more … 2021 State Duma elections: first statistical estimates
Preliminary findings of observation of the September 19, 2021, State Duma elections
This is a preliminary statement on findings of observation on the main voting day, September 19, 2021, by the 'Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights "Golos".' Golos ran long-term and short-term observation of all stages of the campaign. In the course of the elections, the united call center's hotline received 5,943 calls. The 'Map of Violations' received 4,973 reports of alleged violations by noon 20 September, Moscow time, including 3,787 on the voting days.
Read more … Preliminary findings of observation of the September 19, 2021, State Duma elections
Voting Day II: A Brief Overview
This is a brief overview of election monitoring findings on the Second Voting Day, September 18, 2021 by citizen observers of the 'Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights "Golos"'.
Voting Day 1: A Brief Overview
This is a brief overview of election monitoring findings on the First Voting Day by citizen observers of the 'Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights "Golos"'.
The election campaign and administrative mobilization of voters in September 19, 2021 elections
The September 19, 2021 elections are marked by growing pressure on media and individual journalists, attempts at blocking information about "Smart Voting", and massive coercion of voters to vote and register for e-voting and mobile voting. In parallel, social media has been growing in importance for years as a space of more freedom and an alternative information channel. Here are the main findings of the report that focuses on the impact of these two antipodal trends.
'The three heroes': more than a third of social media mentions are related to United Russia, CPRF, and the New People party
This report covers the monitoring of social networks from the 10th to the 11th week of the election campaign (August 23 to September 5) to the Russian State Duma, scheduled for September 19, 2021.
Residents of Russia-Occupied East Ukrainian Territories Encouraged to Vote in 2021 State Duma Elections
One aspect of the 2021 Russian parliamentary elections that differentiates them from previous federal elections is the potential participation in the voting process of dozens of thousands of people located on the Ukrainian territories outside of control of the Ukrainian authorities and not recognized as part of Russia by the Russian Federation itself.
Arrests, bribery, threats
This is the seventh overview of reports of possible violations of electoral legislation gathered via the 'Map of Violations' by the 'Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights "Golos"' between September 6 and September 12. Since the beginning of the election campaign, 945 messages from 72 regions have been published on the Map.
Arrests, arson, and being fired for refusing to register for remote voting
This is the sixth overview of reports of possible violations of electoral legislation gathered via the 'Map of Violations' by the Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights 'Golos' between August 30 and September 5. In total, from August 30 to September 1, 125 messages have been received by the Map.
Read more … Arrests, arson, and being fired for refusing to register for remote voting
Two universes: unlike on television, in social networks, United Russia and the Communist Party are almost head-to-head
This report covers the monitoring of social networks from the 5th to the 9th week (July 20 - August 22) of the election campaign to the Russian State Duma, scheduled for September 19, 2021.
Vladimir Putin plans to win Russia’s parliamentary election no matter how unpopular his party is
Despite its dismal approval rating, Russian President Vladimir Putin's ruling political party can – and likely will – win a constitutional majority in September's legislative elections.
‘Imaginary’ campaign boards and an assignment to vote in prisons
This is the fifth overview of reports of possible violations of electoral legislation gathered via the 'Map of Violations' by the Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights 'Golos' between August 23 and August 29. In total, 100 messages have been received by the Map during this period.
Read more … ‘Imaginary’ campaign boards and an assignment to vote in prisons
Consequences of the ‘law against the Anti-Corruption Foundation’: opposition candidates are denied participation in elections
The Moscow City Court has designated the Anti-Corruption Foundation, Alexey Navalny's Headquarters and the Citizens’ Rights Protection Foundation as 'extremist' organizations. Inter alia, it implies the prohibition to participate in elections.
The authorities have proceeded to banning pro-opposition candidates from running to the State Duma and other legislative bodies on a pretext of involvement in Navalny's projects.
The outcomes of nomination and registration of candidates to the State Duma of the Russian Federation
The elections of the State Duma of Russia of the eighth convocation are marked by considerable tightening of rules for candidate nomination and registration. In fact, the rules are much worse than in 2016, when the current membership of the parliament was elected. Run on the background of harsh restrictions on freedom of expression and information and freedom of assembly and association, the elections are accompanied by a political crackdown against the most active pro-opposition citizens.
Pressure on voters and state control over social media accounts
This is the fourth overview of reports of possible violations of electoral legislation gathered via the 'Map of Violations' by the Movement for the Defense of Voters' Rights 'Golos' between August 16 and August 22. In total, 98 messages have been received by the Map in that period.
Read more … Pressure on voters and state control over social media accounts
Uneven access and unbalanced coverage: media monitoring findings after eight weeks of the campaign
Equality of rights of candidates in media coverage of their election campaign is one of the most important conditions for holding free and democratic elections. For a significant part of Russians, television remains to be one of the main sources of information. During the election campaign, the influence of television in shaping the attitude of the majority of voters towards elections and candidates is often decisive. Here is a summary of monitoring findings for the five main federal television channels during the first eight weeks of the campaign.
PCR tests for voters and candidate flights at public expense
This is the third overview of reports of possible violations of electoral legislation gathered via the 'Map of Violations' by the Movement for the Defense of Voters' Rights 'Golos' between August 9 and August 15. Since the beginning of the election campaign, 452 messages from 62 regions have been published on the Map.
Read more … PCR tests for voters and candidate flights at public expense
Statement on the continuation of the work of the Movement 'Golos' after being included in the 'Foreign agents' registry
On August 18, the Ministry of Justice of Russia included the Movement 'Golos' as the first unregistered organisation into the registry of unregistered public associations performing the functions of a foreign agent. Here is the translation of their statement.
Political and Legal Peculiarities of September 2021 Regional and Local Elections
According to the CEC data as of 9 July 2021, 4,370 elections and referenda are scheduled for 19 September 2021, including elections to the State Duma, nine gubernatorial elections (new heads will be elected in three more regions), 39 elections to regional parliaments, and 11 elections of representative bodies of regional centres. Here's an overview of legal regulations and peculiarities of these races.
Read more … Political and Legal Peculiarities of September 2021 Regional and Local Elections
Open appeal of the 'Golos' Movement to the President of the Russian Federation Vladimir Putin
In 2021, the Russian Central Election Commission decided to scrap open video broadcasts from the polling stations – a feature of Russian elections since 2012. The Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights 'Golos' has appealed to the President to help overturn this decision.
The administrative resource is gaining momentum, and independent candidates continue to face registration denials
This is the second overview of reports of possible violations of electoral legislation gathered via the 'Map of Violations' by the Movement for the Defense of Voters' Rights 'Golos' between August 2 and August 8.
Russian elections again without OSCE observation
The OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights and the Parliamentary Assembly will not deploy international election observation missions to the 2021 State Duma elections due to major limitations imposed on the institutions. Announcing the decision, ODIHR Director noted that the ability "to independently determine the number of observers necessary for us to observe effectively and credibly is essential to all international observation."
Read more … Russian elections again without OSCE observation
CEC restricts journalists' access to the electoral process
On 28 July 2021, the Central Election Commission adopted a new media accreditation procedure that restricts media access to observe and report on the electoral process. The new rules violate the freedom of media editorial policy and may significantly reduce the transparency of the election process.
Read more … CEC restricts journalists' access to the electoral process
‘Extremists’, ‘foreign agents’, and the abuse of administrative resource
This is the first overview of reports of possible violations of electoral legislation gathered via the 'Map of Violations' by the Movement for the Defense of Voters' Rights 'Golos' between June 22 and August 1.
Read more … ‘Extremists’, ‘foreign agents’, and the abuse of administrative resource
No public video broadcast from the polling stations during the September elections
Less than two months before the elections, the Russian Central Election Commission (CEC) decided to scrap open video broadcasts from the polling stations, which have been the feature of Russian elections since 2012.
Read more … No public video broadcast from the polling stations during the September elections
19 times: How the election law was changed before the 2021 State Duma elections
Since the last State Duma elections in 2016, lawmakers have introduced 19 amendments to the election law. In the year leading up to the State Duma elections in September 2021 alone, seven significant legislative amendments have been introduced, six of them in less than four months before the start of the campaign.
Read more … 19 times: How the election law was changed before the 2021 State Duma elections
No tolerance for dissent: the state of Russian media ahead of 2021 elections
After almost a decade of crackdowns on big players, the landscape of critical journalism in Russia is dominated by local or smaller niche projects. But if the 2020-2021 trend of relentless attacks on media, journalists, and bloggers continues, many of these small projects are not likely to survive into the autumn. The regime makes it pretty clear that it no longer intends to tolerate any dissent.
Read more … No tolerance for dissent: the state of Russian media ahead of 2021 elections
What are "foreign agents" and "undesirable organizations"?
The laws on "foreign agent" and "undesirable organizations" continue to hamper the work of affected organizations, stigmatize and damage their reputation, and isolate the civil society from international cooperation and support. What are these provisions and how are they being applied?
Read more … What are "foreign agents" and "undesirable organizations"?
Five years of silence: More than 20 State Duma lawmakers haven't said a word in parliament since they were elected in 2016
The Russian State Duma's seventh convocation is coming to the end of its five-year term. And according to a new report from iStories and Znak.com, dozens of its deputies haven't said a word in a parliamentary session since they were elected in 2016. Others haven't put forward a single bill. Be that as it may, this hasn't stopped these lawmakers from collecting high salaries and planning to put their names on the ballot for the State Duma election coming up in September.
Deprival of passive suffrage – who cannot run in the 2021 Duma Elections and why
According to election observers, recent amendments further limiting citizens' passive suffrage constitute a "fifth wave" of depriving Russians of their right to stand for election since the collapse of the USSR. New restrictions have a particular impact on politically active citizens.
Read more … Deprival of passive suffrage – who cannot run in the 2021 Duma Elections and why
Online Voting Testing in the Russian Federation: Observers’ Assessment
In May, the Russian Federation has tested a new system of remote electronic voting. The Movement in Defense of Voters' Rights "Golos" observed the testing phase, took part in the voting, and shared their conclusions and recommendations in a respective report.
Read more … Online Voting Testing in the Russian Federation: Observers’ Assessment
Conditions for Citizen Election Observation in the Russian Federation Ahead of the 2021 Duma Elections
Opportunities for independent citizen election observation and civil society space in general have been shrinking steadily in Russia over the past decade. Recently, further restrictions have been adopted that limit the ability of citizens to independently monitor electoral processes.
How Authorities Stripped Russians Of Choice
Over the past 14 years, the authorities have blocked 120,000 candidates from participating in elections of various levels, depriving millions of Russian citizens of the right to choose their representatives.
Hundreds of Thousands of Extremists
Russia has finally outlawed Alexey Navalny's political and anti-corruption movement. Here's how the crackdown affects activists, journalists, and ordinary supporters.
The Law Prohibiting People Involved in Activities of Extremist Organizations from Participating in Elections Is Adopted
The President of Russia approved the law prohibiting those who are "involved" in the activities of an extremist organization from running in elections.
Now Extremists. How Alexei Navalny's Supporters May Be Persecuted
On June 9, the Moscow City Court, based on the charges by the Moscow Prosecutor's Office, recognized the Anti-Corruption Foundation (FBK), the Foundation for the Protection of Citizens' Rights, and the headquarters of Alexei Navalny as extremist organizations. Now, many citizens are under a threat of pressure and persecution.
Read more … Now Extremists. How Alexei Navalny's Supporters May Be Persecuted
Implementation of OSCE/ODIHR Recommendations to Russia Following 2003-2018 Federal Elections
Between 2003 and 2018, OSCE/ODIHR published 139 recommendations on how to improve the conduct of elections in Russia. In the run-up to the State Duma elections in 2021, Russia has fully implemented just over 10% of them. Some have been tackled more promptly than others.
Online Elections in Russia: Manipulating Votes in a New Digital Realm
Ahead of the State Duma election on September 19, 2021, Russia just tested its remote electronic voting system. While the Central Election Commission of the Russian Federation (CEC) is preparing the report about the results of the test, election monitors say Russia's electronic voting system is a black box.
Read more … Online Elections in Russia: Manipulating Votes in a New Digital Realm
New Legislation Aims To Block Opposition Candidates
The Russian authorities are expected to orchestrate a result in the upcoming State Duma elections that will give United Russia a clear majority of seats. This does not mean, however, that the manipulation of the electoral process by the authorities is complete. In a limited number of competitive districts, true opposition candidates including candidates who are associated with Aleksei Navalny have a real chance of winning if they are allowed to run. In recent weeks, steps have been taken to block these 'undesirable' candidates from participating.
Read more … New Legislation Aims To Block Opposition Candidates
The new-old Central Election Commission: an authentic renewal or a superficial touch up?
On March 19, 2021, the new composition of the Central Election Commission (CEC) of the Russian Federation was revealed. Out of 15 members, eight new people joined the CEC. In particular, the new Commission has been 'reinforced' by bureaucrats from the Presidential Administration, the State Duma, and the Civic Chamber (a consultative civil society institution closely linked to the government).
Read more … The new-old Central Election Commission: an authentic renewal or a superficial touch up?
Questionable credentials of the Russian Delegation to PACE after flawed Duma elections 2021
Briefing by the European Platform for Democratic Elections
SUMMARY
Independent election experts have described the 2021 Duma elections as the dirtiest elections in Russia's history. The lack of public control, the deprivation of ca. 9 Mio Russian citizens of the right to stand for election and the massive manipulation through application of uncontrolled e-voting have turned the Duma elections into a farce. The holding of elections on the annexed territory of Crimea and the inclusion of ca. 500.000 votes from inhabitants of the occupied Eastern Ukraine puts the legitimacy of the current State Duma and the new PACE delegation additionally under question. This breach of Protocol 1 § 3 is another substantial shortcoming of the Russian government with regard to the European Convention on Human Rights and should be sanctioned by PACE and the Committee of Ministers during the upcoming Winter Session of PACE accordingly. What are the options?
- the right to be appointed rapporteur
- the right to be a member of an ad hoc committee on observation of elections
- the right to represent the Assembly in Council of Europe bodies as well as external institutions and organizations, both institutionally and on occasional basis. The application of these left-over sanctions would be an absolute minimum option that the PACE should consider during its Winter session 2022.
With this special briefing, the European Platform for Democratic Elections wants to shed a light on the past Duma elections. André Härtel, PhD, Researcher at the Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, Berlin will assess the Russian membership in the Council of Europe as a challenge for the credibility and functionality of the institution and Prof. Dr. Caroline von Gall will look deeper into the question whether Russia’s membership in the Council of Europe can still guarantee legal action for Russian Citizen at the European Court on Human Rights.
Why Russia's PACE delegates cannot be considered legally elected parliamentarians
Independent election experts have described the 2021 Duma elections as the dirtiest in Russia's history.
Main intrigues were:
The elections took place with the international public excluded and massive restrictions on domestic election observation
Restrictions on the right to stand for election
Since the last State Duma elections in 2016, there have been 19 changes to electoral law, six of them just before the September 2021 elections. The most important changes were aimed at restricting the right to stand for election. Firstly, Russian citizens can now be deprived of the right to stand for election even for minor offences and misdemeanours - including participation in protests. Secondly, with the so-called "extremism law" passed 3.5 months before the elections and the classification of Alexei Navalny's organizations as extremist only 5 days after adoption of the new law, all candidates of pro-Navalny organizations were prevented from standing for election. The law is also illegal because it is retroactive. This means that anyone who has already been involved in activities of Navalny's organizations in any way from summer 2020 onwards will not be able to stand for election until at least summer 2024 (for activists) and 2026 (for leaders). This means they will not be able to run in the upcoming presidential elections 2024 and perhaps even parliamentary elections in 2026. Anyone convicted of continued activity in Navalny's now-banned organizations faces up to six years in prison.
According to experts' estimates, a total of about 9 million Russian voters have lost the right to stand for election as a result of the recent law amendments (about 8 % of the total number of voters). This number is expected to increase significantly in the future.
Massive falsification through e-voting
In seven regions - including Moscow e-voting was carried out for the first time. In Moscow, 2 million voters (almost a third of the electoral roll) registered for internet voting. In Moscow, the results of e-voting were only announced the next day following the election, after a meeting between Ella Pamfilova (Head of the Central Election Commission) and Vladimir Putin. The e-voting turned the results of the ballot box election upside down: With an official turnout of 96.5%, nine constituency winners of the ballot box election lost their seats to pro-Kremlin candidates after the e-voting results were included into the final vote count.
On 23 September, the Russian president's press secretary, Dmitry Peskov, said that the practice of e-voting should be spread as widely as possible.
Conclusion:
Looking at the data available, analyzed and compiled by independent election experts, it is clear that the deputies of the Duma elected in 2021, and thus also the PACE delegation, are not legitimized by free elections. The holding of elections on the illegally annexed Crimea and the access to elections for inhabitants of the occupied territories in Eastern Ukraine (ca 500.000 voters) is another factor that puts the legitimacy of the State Duma under question. This means a violation of Protocol 1 § 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights and should be sanctioned by PACE in the upcoming winter session accordingly.
PECULIARITIES OF THE RUSSIAN DELEGATION TO THE PACE
Three members of the Russian delegation asking for credentials at the PACE Winter Session are on EU Sanction lists:
Leonid Slutsky
Aleksey Chepa
Just Russia
Maria Butina
United Russia, Kirov Region
Evgeniy Popov
United Russia
Olga Kazakova
United Russia
Russian Membership in the Council of Europe – Challenge for the credibility and functionality of the institution
André Härtel, PhD, Researcher at the Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, Berlin
Council of Europe Department for Policy Planning 2012-2015
Recommendations to Members of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe:
Members of new delegation should focus on the following:
Can Russia’s membership in the Council of Europe still guarantee legal action for Russian Citizen at the European Court on Human Rights?
Prof. Dr. Caroline von Gall is an Associate Professor (Juniorprofessor) at the Institute for Eastern European Law at the University of Cologne
Art. 8 of the Pace Rules of Procedure provides that credentials may be challenged in the event of serious violations of the primacy of law and the obligation to "co-operate sincerely and actively in the common pursuit of human rights, democracy and the rule of law". This corresponds with the membership requirements in general.
In fact, Russia did not even fulfil the requirements at the moment of accession. Instead, exceptions were defined from the beginning to justify membership. Central to this was that membership
This exception to the principle is a problem overall, because it is precisely the European Convention on Human Rights that is built on voluntary membership, the principle of subsidiarity. The Council of Europe has hardly any enforcement instruments of its own. Structurally, the Council of Europe cannot work against individual member states. At the same time, rights are granted: all member states can elect judges to the ECtHR and influence policy. A member state that does not fulfil the basic requirements as laid down in the European Convention on Human Rights always reveals the weakness of the Council of Europe.
Exceptions can therefore only be justified if, despite the lack of membership requirements, membership serves the aims of the Council of Europe as a whole.
There are no indications of this today in the case of Russia. Russia more than clearly refuses to engage in a dialogue on the implementation of the Council of Europe's goals.
While Russia recognized the values of the Council of Europe, the primacy of international treaties over Russian law and the importance of human rights, at least on paper, in its 1993 constitution, the Russian government has now expressly abandoned them.
Even the access to the European Court on Human Rights for Russian citizen cannot in itself serve the aims of the Council of Europe if the Russian government refuses to implement its judgements.
It does create individual satisfaction and objective reappraisal.
However, the Russian example in particular shows that the possibilities of appealing to the ECtHR are limited. Individual complaints can only be used to deal with individual cases. In view of the profound structural violations of the European Convention on Human Rights through the Russian government, however, almost every citizen could theoretically claim a violation of rights. And if citizens had the know-how and the resources to file a complaint, the ECtHR would be massively overburdened. As of 30.11.2021, 16,300 cases from Russia were pending before the ECtHR.
It is therefore extremely problematic that the in the case of Russia judgements are only pronounced years later, often after individuals have been imprisoned for a long time. The long duration of proceedings in the case of Memorial and the NGOs affected by the Russian law on Foreign Agents has proven to be particularly precarious. Memorial had already filed a first complaint against the Foreign Agent Law in 2013. But the verdict is still pending. Since then, almost the entire organized NGO landscape has disappeared.
But if the verdicts are then only pronounced after more than 9 years, they are not only a symbol of late justice. The finding of a breach of the law after years of repression and extensive destruction of Russian NGOs without any prospect of being able to enforce the verdict then also becomes a demonstration of power by the Kremlin. Vladimir Putin can show with every unimplemented verdict that international law cannot protect against profound human rights violations. And that is why he also wants to show the powerlessness of the West. These judgements contribute to this demonstration of power, also in the Navalny case.
In this respect, mistakes have been made in the past: Precisely because Russian membership to the Council of Europe was ultimately justified primarily by the possibility of legal action, the complaints should have been used more in their leverage function. Faster procedures and political pressure on the Russian government to enforce the rulings would have been necessary. Here, the Parliamentary Assembly and the Committee of Ministers could have been used more. In the Navalny case, infringement proceedings under Article 46 of the European Convention on Human Rights would have been conceivable; in principle, states can also file state complaints.
In 2019, Memorial had already warned against the argument of the possibility of legal action and described it as a trap. If criticism of the Russian human rights situation had been spared in recent years precisely in order to prevent Russia's withdrawal from the Council of Europe, because the citizens should retain the possibility of legal action, then in any case not much would have been gained for human rights in the Memorial case.
Against this background, the possibility of legal action can only be an argument if the decisions are made promptly and if there is some reasonable hope that the judgments will also be implemented, which is not the case.
Ultimately, one must be careful not to recognize the annexation of Crimea with the confirmation of credentials to the Russian Delegation.